The highest-rated restaurants in Smithtown, Suffolk County. Ranked by customer ratings and reviews. Updated 2026.
A standout Lithuanian restaurant on Long Island. Unique Eastern European dishes made with authentic r
The food is delicious, well seasoned and filling. Great vegan options available.
Exceptional sandwiches made with quality ingredients. The roast beef is sliced fresh daily.
A hidden gem in Nesconset with outstanding Italian food. The homemade sauces and fresh pasta are sup
great small place with a wonderful farm to table menu! reasonable prices and great service.
A neighborhood Italian favorite with consistently great pasta, pizza and attentive service.
Upscale Italian dining in Hauppauge with an extensive wine list and impeccable service.
They also had a few specials that sounded delicious. Overall for a new restaurant the experience was
A trendy gastropub with creative small plates, craft cocktails and a lively atmosphere in Hauppauge.
An authentic Italian restaurant with a cozy atmosphere. Excellent homemade pasta and fresh seafood.